[ 3 / a / adv / an / asp / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / g / gd / int / jp / k / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / o / out / p / po / sci / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wsg / x]

/tv/ - Television & Film

<< back to board
[Delete this thread]

Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)17:25 UTC+1 No.46802898 Report

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2700094/A-scientists-favourite-film-2001-A-Space-Odyssey-Poll-reveals-academics-favourite-sci-fi-movies-time.html

What does /tv/ think of this list? Are the academics right?

1. 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)
2. Blade Runner (1982)
3. Alien (1979)
4. Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977)
5. Aliens (1986)
6. Star Wars (1977)
7. Brazil (1985)
8. Metropolis (1927)
9. The Terminator (1984)
10. The Empire Strikes Back (1980)
11. ET the Extra-Terrestrial (1982)
12. The Thing (1982)
13. The Matrix (1999)
14. Moon (2009)
15. Stalker (1979)
16. Terminator 2: Judgment Day (1991)
17. Solaris (1972)
18. Children of Men (2006)
19. The Fly (1986)
20. Forbidden Planet (1956)
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)17:27 UTC+1 No.46802944 Report

>Moon (2009)
>no Primer
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)17:31 UTC+1 No.46803031 Report

>>46802898
>Terminator 2: Judgment Day (1991)

but the original was better.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)17:46 UTC+1 No.46803348 Report

why do people like films made before 1980?
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)18:38 UTC+1 No.46804578 Report

>Academic film studies
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)18:50 UTC+1 No.46804829 Report

>>46803348
it's called nostalgia
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:11 UTC+1 No.46805318 Report

>>46804578
it's a respected field.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:13 UTC+1 No.46805365 Report

>"academics"
>imdb level taste
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:15 UTC+1 No.46805404 Report

>>46805365

>STEM fag
>having patrician taste in any art form
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:18 UTC+1 No.46805521 Report

>Episode IV over Episode V

Academics confirmed for good taste.

IV > V > III > VI > I > II
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:20 UTC+1 No.46805567 Report

>Solaris that low
fucking 'Murican plebs
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:20 UTC+1 No.46805579 Report

>Stalker (1979)

only good film on that list.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:24 UTC+1 No.46805715 Report

>>46802944

this

also,

>Alien over Aliens
>T1 over T2

Someone needs to tell this guy to get some taste.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:26 UTC+1 No.46805776 Report

>>46805567
Except this was a British poll
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:27 UTC+1 No.46805806 Report

>>46805715
>James Cameron cock gargler gets told
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:27 UTC+1 No.46805821 Report

>>46802898
>scientists
>not a bunch of massive plebes

No wonder humanity is stagnating.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:28 UTC+1 No.46805836 Report

Wow, this list is total shit. STEMfags really are autistic.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:28 UTC+1 No.46805848 Report

>aliens
ayy lmao
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:29 UTC+1 No.46805878 Report

>18. Children of Men

Impressed.jpg
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:31 UTC+1 No.46805929 Report

So /tv/ thinks 2001 and Blade Runner aren't patrician films?
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:34 UTC+1 No.46806001 Report

No
>event horizon
>europa report

plebs
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:35 UTC+1 No.46806039 Report

>>46805715
>Aliens over Alien
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:36 UTC+1 No.46806054 Report

>>46804829
>Nostalgia
>Metropolis (1927)
There isn't a single voter alive when this was released.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:36 UTC+1 No.46806061 Report

>no Sunshine
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:36 UTC+1 No.46806072 Report

worst choice is aliens
alien is in the right place though
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:37 UTC+1 No.46806086 Report

>>46802898
>12. The Thing (1982)
>13. The Matrix (1999)
top sides
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:39 UTC+1 No.46806158 Report

>Aliens making the list at all
Bunch of fucking retards. Down's sydrome level straight jacket autistics. Why must plebs run the world? Only list that belongs on is "top 10 biggest bastardizations of classic movies."
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:50 UTC+1 No.46806464 Report

Pleb here. My favourite film on that list is Moon. I tried watching Stalker a while ago but couldn't get into it, is it worth another go?
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:50 UTC+1 No.46806466 Report

>>46806158
>not enjoying sequels that miss the point of the original and turn it into GUNS N EXPLOSIONS the movie
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)19:54 UTC+1 No.46806586 Report

>>46806054
Don't be a retard pls. There's also a movie from 2006 but those are just exceptions. Most of the films are from when these scientist were young enough to later feel nostalgic about those movies.

To say that there has been 7 great sci-fi movies from 1980s and only 1 from 2000s is just ludicrous. Gramps can't get with the times.
>>
Anonymous 07/21/14(Mon)20:09 UTC+1 No.46807018 Report

>>46802898
>Are the academics right?
Yes.
All the content on this website comes from 4chan.org. All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster. 4chanArchive is not affiliated with 4chan.